In this issue...
Honeywell v.WCAB (Wagner)
1
Vol. XI No.3
March 2005
COMPENSATION
NEWS
MONTHLY REPORT
90 Days to deny injury runs from the date
the applicant files the claim form
This is a Supreme
Court decision.
T
he applicant claimed an
industrial injury to his
body and psyche for a
period of January 1, 1995
through October 16,1998.
The company medical record
indicated in July that the
applicant's private physician had
prescribed the applicant
medications for work related
stress.
On October 16, the
applicant's wife called the
employer and informed the
employer the applicant had been
admitted to a psychiatric facility
for a nervous breakdown. The
hospital records did indicate work
problems.
A claim form was not sent
until January 1999. The claim
form was returned January 15,
1999 and the case was denied
March 31, 1999.
The matter was tried before a
Workers' Compensation Judge
(WCJ) on the grounds that the
employer did not deny the claim
timely pursuant to Labor Code
section 5402. Therefore, the case
should be presumed
compensable. The WCJ found it
compensable on the grounds the
employer had sufficient
knowledge in October.
The Workers'
Compensation Appeals
Board issued an en banc
decision on petition for
reconsideration and
rescinded the WCJ decision.
The case eventually made it
to the Court of Appeal and
finally the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court ruled
that the 90 days runs from
the filing of the claim form
only. The employer can be
estopped from the running of
the 90 days from the filing of
the claim form only under
three circumstances. These
are elucidated in the
decision and will be applied
on a case by case basis.
=================
Editor: Harvey Brown
Firm: Samuelsen, Gonzalez,
Valenzuela and Brown
Address: 18500 Von
Karman #470, Irvine
Phone: 949 252-1300
Click here for printable version