In this issue..
Browning-Ferris Industries v.
WCAB, Salter
Vol. XIV No.
III
March 2008
COMPENSATION
NEWS
MONTHLY REPORT
Court of Appeal indicates apportionment
under Brodie decision is correct
This is an appellate
decision that was not
published.
T
his is a significant
decision involving
interpretation of
subtracting a prior award on a
100 per cent case.
The applicant worked for the
employer for 16 years and
suffered numerous workers'
compensation injuries. In 1994 it
was stipulated the applicant had a
60 per cent permanent disability
for these injuries.
The applicant continued to
work for the employer and filed
two new claims. The applicant
did not reopen the prior cases.
The parties stipulated at trial the
applicant was 100 per cent
disabled. The workers'
compensation judge (WCJ) found
that there was only one
cumulative trauma instead of two
injuries. The judge only allowed
the monetary amount of the prior
award for 60 per cent jto be
deducted from a 100 percent
award, instead of deducting the
percentage. The Workers'
Compensation Appeals Board
(WCAB) eventually denied the
employers petition for
reconsideration.
The appellate court at first
denied review. The employer then
filed a writ with the Supreme
Court who transferred the case
back to the appellate court with
the instruction to vacate the
decision.
On review this court relies on
Brodie v. WCAB (2007) 40 Cal
4
th
1313. Brodie evaluated old
case law under the Fuentes
decision and decided the changes
in the apportionment law with
SB899 did not change using
Formula A as was used in the
Fuentes decision.
Therefore, in this case even
though the applicant was 100
percent disabled, the prior 60
percent needed to be subtracted.
Thus, 60 per cent is subtracted
from 100 per cent and the
applicant only gets 40 per cent.
That is the applicant gets the
dollar value of 40 percent for that
date of injury.
It is of interest to note the
WCJ only found one injury
although two were filed.
=================
Editor: Harvey Brown
Firm: Samuelsen, Gonzalez,
Valenzuela and Brown
Address: 18881 Von
Karman # 250 Irvine 92612
Phone: 949 252-1300
Click here for printable version